Contact Us
Call thecounter.
Phone is fastest. Email reaches the same inbox. For special cuts, holiday standing orders, and whole-animal items, we need 48 hours.
Reach the counter
Phone is fastest during shop hours. Outside of hours leave a voicemail or email — we'll come back to you the next business day.
At a glance
- Address
- 96 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
- Phone
- (516) 273-6733
- info@thebaybutcher.com
- Special orders
- 48 hours' notice
Hours
When we're open.
Closed Mondays. Holiday hours may vary — call to confirm during Christmas, Easter, Thanksgiving, and the 4th of July week.
- Monday
- Closed
- Tuesday – Saturday
- 12 — 6 pm
- Sunday
- 10 am — 3 pm