The Bay Butcher

Oyster Bay · since 2020

A butcher and a seafood counter on South Street. Cut to order, served to standard.

Begin
A5 Japanese snow-aged Wagyu

A5 Wagyu · Hyōgo prefecture

N° 01

Meat

Cut to order,never to display.

Dry-aged USDA Prime, A5 Japanese Wagyu, heritage Duroc pork, New Zealand lamb, and veal — broken down whole in the shop, portioned to your spec at the counter.

Tell us the table, the technique, the evening. The case is the conversation.

Fresh seafood on ice

Day-boat selection

N° 02

Fish

Day-boat fresh,on ice by service.

Salmon, branzino, tuna, halibut, Chilean sea bass. Head-on shellfish — clams, oysters, mussels, lobster, crab. Specialty cuts: octopus, scallops, caviar.

With advance notice we can source seasonal fish to spec for your order.

Visit the shop

Come in.

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday – Saturday
12 — 6 pm
Sunday
10 am — 3 pm

Call ahead for special cuts, dry-aged whole loins, holiday standing orders, and the larger pieces — we hold the case for the order with your name on it.